Everyone knows the story of Cinderella. But Gregory Maguire takes us a step backward to see the story behind the story. He deromanticizes the fairy tale and creates a realism behind it, adding a new dimension to a traditional story while staying true to the original framework.
This is my fourth read for Fall Into Reading 2009 challenge. Four more to go.
Author : Gregory Maguire
Date of First Publication : October 6, 1999 (Hardcover)
Publisher : William Morrow
ISBN-10: 0060392827
ISBN-13: 978-0060392826
Hardcover: 384 pages
The Story :
Margarethe and her two daughters, Iris (plain but clever) and Ruth (an ugly simpleton), flee England in the dead of night and sail for Holland. Destitute and friendless, the family is forced to beg for their survival. At last, a painter offers them board and lodging in exchange for housework and the permission for the plain daughter, Iris, to sit as a model for his canvas. So for a while, the family is happily fed and secure.
A prosperous tulip merchant, Cornelius van den Meer, drops by at the painter’s studio one day and offers to buy the painting of Iris. However as a condition of sale, Iris must accompany the painting to live in the great house and serve as a companion to Clara, the merchant’s extraordinarily beautiful but reclusive daughter. Margarethe sees this as an opportunity for greener pastures and loses no time insinuating herself and her other daughter in the deal. Soon, she makes herself indispensable to the van den Meer household.
As tragedy would have it, Cornelius’ wife and Clara’s mother, dies in childbirth. Gritty Margarethe sees the opportunity to secure her family’s future and finds a way to marry the merchant. Meanwhile, Clara, depressed and insecure upon her mother’s death and the marriage of her father to Margarethe, consigns herself to the kitchen, covers herself with ash and acquires a new name, Cinderella. She declares her beauty a burden and seeks solace in the anonymity of kitchen drudgery.
But, tragedy does strike twice. The tulip trade is disrupted; so soon, the merchant finds himself on the brink of poverty. Unwilling to face hunger and indignity again, Margarethe makes a last ditch effort. She prepares herself and her daughters for the coming ball where she, in her determination, believes plain Iris would capture the Prince’s interest with her intelligence. Beautiful Clara, to Margarethe’s delight, refuses to go and parade herself for the Prince. Margarethe knows that Clara’s beauty would surely awe the Prince and that her marriage to him, coupled with her disdain for her stepmother, would land her family back in the poorhouse.
But unbeknown to Margarethe, Iris convinces Clara to get out of her shell and attend the party of the decade. She secures a gown and a veil for Clara to hide under. Clara appears at the ball, radiantly mysterious and gets the Prince’s undivided attention. The rest is history with the glass slipper, coach, the midnight run and all.
The Review :
Between the stark delineations of the good and the bad in any fairy tale, Maguire steps in to create a gray world — is the bad really that bad or just misunderstood?
Much like history or any story for that matter, fairy tales are told from a point of view, this being mostly from the hero’s . Gregory Maguire is known as an author who loves to turn a fairy tale inside out with a resounding concept : “Let’s hear it from the other side”.
As with “Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West”, Maguire gives a voice to the villains, , telling the story from their perspective, and imbuing these much maligned characters with more humanity. His intention is to relate how the forces of personality and circumstance that influence reactions and decisions, coupled with the judgmental character of human nature, easily cast people into roles of iniquity or seeming goodness. Hence, there are always two sides to a coin; and it is never two-dimensional.
In this vein, the author tackles duality in such concepts as beauty, love, compassion, greed — for instance, beauty as both blessing and curse, greed as both corruptible and necessary; so that this is no mere fairy tale rehash but one with a purpose to provide some rumination on the abstracts of good and bad.
To Read Or Not To Read :
“Confessions Of An Ugly Stepsister” holds almost true to the Cinderella plot outline, except for the setting, Holland, and an event toward the end. It is quite entertaining how Maguire weaves a realistic background to the simple framework of the fairy tale. Told through the perspective of Iris, one of Cinderella’s or Clara’s stepsisters, we get a grip on why the Cinderella story had been spun so.
Because of the author’s inclination toward establishing the events and characters on which Cinderella’s story evolved to be what it is, readers may find half of the book a bit slow paced.
Although Maguire’s framework is commendable and his writing intentions, successful; there are nevertheless, a vagueness in Maguire’s writing here that I wish were clearer. To cite a few: Clara (Cinderella) is somewhat a vague character and the reader may not be able to get a good understanding on what makes her tick. We are given the impression of a recluse, someone afraid of life. However, she suddenly does an about face by being very bold with the Prince, a stranger, at the ball. Also, Clara’s experience as a child at the windmill is left to imagination. What was it really? This, and some others, may irritate a reader who appreciates straightforwardness and specifics; but for those can live with conjecture, this shouldn’t be much of a bother.
In A Nutshell :
Although, not as good as his other novel, “Wicked….” , “Confessions Of An Ugly Stepsister” is nevertheless, still a pleasurable read, a satisfying deconstruction and reinvention of Cinderella that would appeal to those who love stories thought “out of the box”.
My Mark : Very Good
October 18, 2009 at 3:45 am
Hi, Jo! Thanks for reviewing this book as I’ve always been interested about it. I really love to read about alternative narratives to popular stories. (They’re much more realistic. Hehehe. And everything’s not treated as black and white.) I have wicked here somewhere in my TBR pile. I’ll just look for it.
By the way, have you read any work by Angela Carter? She came out with a collection of short stories entitled The Bloody Chamber, which is actually about her own take of popular fairy tales such as Snow White, Puss in Boots, and Bluebeard. Some of those stories are quite erotic.
Also, you might want to check out the original versions of fairy tales as some of them have very macabre touches. I’m sure you know that, in the original little mermaid, she dies and turns to foam. But I think you’ll be surprised to read the original Sleeping Beauty. It has sex, murder, necrophilia, cannibalism, and other perverse elements.
October 18, 2009 at 4:55 pm
Peter, thanks for the Angela Carter tip. No I haven’t come across this author. Now that you say she has her own twisted fairy tales, I’d like to get my hands on her book!
I’ve known that fairy tales come from actual stories with a dark side. Haven’t really read the originals, though. Ooooh, I would like to read the original Sleeping Beauty. Could you recommend the book on this? And others of the same kind?
Btw, Peter, you might enjoy Wicked. You’ll probably never look at the Wicked Witch of the West the same way again.
October 21, 2009 at 8:05 am
Hi, Jo! I think you can find it online. Anyway, I’ll look for it. It’s by an Italian monk, who really had dirty ideas in his head. Hehehe.
October 21, 2009 at 2:47 pm
A monk with dirty ideas. Sinfully fantabulous! Thanks, Peter! Will look it up.
October 19, 2009 at 6:34 am
I also have Wicked on my TBR pile, although I’ve heard mixed reviews. I hope I get around to reading it this year.
October 19, 2009 at 3:04 pm
I enjoyed it so I hope you will, too, Blooey. Maguire’s concept of retelling The Wizard of Oz from the perspective of the Wicked Witch of the West was so refreshing for me. He mixes fantasy and realism pretty well.
October 21, 2009 at 9:25 pm
Hello from Russia!
Can I quote a post in your blog with the link to you?
October 22, 2009 at 1:40 pm
Sure! With the proper credits (i.e. link to me), I wouldn’t mind at all. In fact, I’ll be flattered. Thanks! 🙂
October 22, 2009 at 12:59 am
Jo, I found a copy of the fairy tale. Here’s the URL:
http://uncoy.com/2006/05/sleeping_beauty_1.html
By the way, we can’t wait to meet you when you come here to Manila. We’ll have long conversations about books, blogging, and pretty much everything else.
October 22, 2009 at 1:26 pm
Hey, thanks, Peter! Read through the link. Boy, a totally twisted Sleeping Beauty story.
Gotta have Basile’s book! This would be a great addition to my little library. 🙂
Oh it would be great to meet you guys…the only people I know who won’t be bored with what many people think as nerdy leisure — reading.
November 27, 2009 at 3:20 pm
Came from Callipider Days book review list. Thanks for the great review. I put it on hold at the library!
November 28, 2009 at 1:59 pm
Thanks a bunch, Susanne. I’d love to hear what you think about it. Thanks for stopping by. 🙂
July 19, 2010 at 4:32 am
[…] Reviews: Book Room Reviews, Books I Done Read, Dogear Diary, Jo’s Bookshelf, Kay’s Bookshelf, Neth Space, Shelf Love, Trish’s Reading Nook Have you reviewed this […]